Hiring

Comparisons 12 min read

EssayGrader vs IntelliAssess: grading essays or running whole tests?

By , Technology Consultant and Trainer - Cloud, DevOps, Java, Data Science

EssayGrader vs IntelliAssess: grading essays or running whole tests?
Contents28
  1. The short answer
  2. Why the two are compared at all
  3. EssayGrader vs IntelliAssess at a glance
  4. What EssayGrader is
  5. What IntelliAssess is
  6. Feature by feature
  7. Length and type of writing
  8. Rubrics and learning your marking
  9. Paper and handwriting
  10. Integrity
  11. Building and running the test
  12. Results and integrations
  13. Languages
  14. One term, two ways
  15. A closer look at EssayGrader's accuracy figure
  16. How far to trust the AI score
  17. Pricing
  18. AI-written work: checking the text or watching the writing
  19. When a test can do part of an essay's job
  20. Two kinds of trust
  21. Word limits and volumes in practice
  22. Getting consistent AI scores in IntelliAssess
  23. Student data
  24. What students see
  25. Monthly or yearly billing
  26. Questions to ask before choosing
  27. Choose EssayGrader if
  28. Choose IntelliAssess if

Key takeaways

  1. 1EssayGrader is free for 100 essays a month; Pro is $14.99 a month with AI-writing and plagiarism checks.
  2. 2It reads handwriting and learns from essays you have graded; IntelliAssess does neither.
  3. 3Its own study reports 94% of scores within one point of teachers on 22,000 essays.
  4. 4IntelliAssess writes and proctors the test too, and scores written answers inside it.

Key takeaways

  1. 1EssayGrader is free for 100 essays a month; Pro is $14.99 a month with AI-writing and plagiarism checks.
  2. 2It reads handwriting and learns from essays you have graded; IntelliAssess does neither.
  3. 3Its own study reports 94% of scores within one point of teachers on 22,000 essays.
  4. 4IntelliAssess writes and proctors the test too, and scores written answers inside it.

EssayGrader vs IntelliAssess compares one of the most-used AI essay graders with an assessment platform that scores written answers inside its own tests. EssayGrader grades essays, papers and DBQs against your rubric or 800+ standards-aligned rubrics, reads handwriting, learns from essays you have graded, and checks for AI writing and plagiarism on paid plans, free for 100 essays a month. IntelliAssess writes the test, proctors it and scores written answers against your rubric at hand-in, from $39 a month. For essays and papers, EssayGrader is the specialist; for tests you set, IntelliAssess does more of the job.

The short answer

Choose EssayGrader if your marking load is essays and papers, including long and handwritten ones, and you want standards-aligned rubrics, revision cycles and AI-writing detection. Choose IntelliAssess if you set tests that mix question types, want them written from your material and proctored, and want the written answers scored in the same place.

Three places student writing comes from and the tools that fit: essays in Google Docs, an LMS or on paper suit CoGrader, EssayGrader or Brisk; written answers inside a test you set suit IntelliAssess; scanned paper exams, maths and code suit Gradescope
The deciding question: where does the writing happen?

Why the two are compared at all

EssayGrader is built for one job: marking essays and papers that students write over days, in Google Docs, an LMS or on paper. IntelliAssess is built for another: writing, delivering, supervising and marking tests, where written answers sit next to choice questions. They overlap only at the written answer. Teachers searching for an EssayGrader alternative who mostly mark long papers should look at CoGrader or Brisk first. Those whose written answers mostly come from tests, or who also need the test written and proctored, are the ones for whom IntelliAssess is worth comparing.

EssayGrader vs IntelliAssess at a glance

EssayGraderIntelliAssess
What it gradesEssays, papers and DBQs from Google Classroom, Canvas, Schoology, uploads or scansEvery answer in its own online tests
Length1,000 to 8,000 words per essay, by planWritten answers inside a test
Rubrics800+ standards-aligned (all 50 states, AP, IB, Common Core), or your ownYour own, or drafted by its rubric generator
Learns your styleFrom essays you upload with your gradesNot described on our pages; you can change any score
HandwritingYes: one class PDF, cursive and printNo
AI-writing and plagiarism checksPro and PremiumNo text checks; proctoring watches the screen for AI tools
Creates and proctors testsNot describedYes
Published accuracy94% within one point on 22,000 essays (own study)No published study
ArabicNot stated on the pages we readWrites and grades in Arabic, right to left
PriceFree for 100 essays a month; Pro $14.99 a monthFree for 25 students; AI grading from $39 a month

What EssayGrader is

EssayGrader reads each paper against your rubric, criterion by criterion, and drafts scores and comments: "You review, adjust and share. You stay in control of every grade." It offers 800+ standards-aligned rubrics, learns from essays you upload with your scores, and its Paper Grader separates a whole class scanned into one PDF and "recognizes cursive, print & messy handwriting". It syncs grades and feedback with Google Classroom, Canvas and Schoology.

On accuracy, it says its grading was tested on 22,000 essays from The Learning Agency's dataset and that scores "matched or landed within 1 point of teacher scores 94% of the time". That is its own study.

What IntelliAssess is

IntelliAssess runs the whole test. Its AI quiz generator writes questions from your files, a YouTube video or a web page, and its rubric generator drafts criteria for each written question. Students take the test online, optionally with proctoring. Choice questions are marked at hand-in and AI grading scores each written answer against every criterion with a comment you can change. Grades sync to Google Classroom.

What it does not do: grade essays written elsewhere, read handwriting, use a state rubric library, or check text for AI writing or plagiarism.

Feature by feature

Length and type of writing

EssayGrader handles essays, research papers and DBQs, with a word limit per essay that rises by plan: 1,000 words on Basic, 3,500 on Pro and 8,000 on Premium. IntelliAssess grades written answers inside a test, from a sentence to a short essay, alongside choice, true or false, fill-in-the-blank and short-answer questions. A ten-page research paper belongs in EssayGrader.

Rubrics and learning your marking

EssayGrader offers 800+ standards-aligned rubrics covering all 50 states, AP, IB and Common Core, or your own, and learns from essays you upload with your grades, so its drafts move toward how you mark. IntelliAssess uses your own criteria or drafts them with its rubric generator, and gives a reason for every criterion score that you can change. Our pages do not describe it learning from your past grades.

Paper and handwriting

EssayGrader's Paper Grader takes a whole class scanned into one PDF, separates it by student and, in its words, "recognizes cursive, print & messy handwriting". IntelliAssess grades only typed answers in its own tests.

Integrity

EssayGrader checks submitted text for AI writing and plagiarism on Pro and Premium. IntelliAssess does not check text; it supervises tests instead, with an ID and selfie check before a proctored test and webcam, microphone, whole-screen and browser checks during it. For a take-home paper, a text check is the only option of the two. For a test sat at home, supervision shows what happened on screen while the answer was written.

Building and running the test

EssayGrader does not describe writing questions or running tests. IntelliAssess writes questions from your files, a YouTube video or a web page, checks each answer key, and runs the test with timers, scheduled starts, shuffling and attempt limits on paid plans.

Results and integrations

EssayGrader syncs grades and feedback with Google Classroom, Canvas and Schoology. IntelliAssess syncs grades and criterion scores with Google Classroom, and its analytics show results by question, topic, question type and rubric criterion, with PDF reports per test, student and submission.

Languages

EssayGrader's pages we read do not mention languages beyond English. IntelliAssess writes and grades in Arabic as well as English, right to left.

One term, two ways

Take an eleventh-grade US history teacher with three classes of 32. Over a term they set two DBQs, one 2,500-word research paper, and three unit tests, each with twenty choice questions and two short written responses.

With EssayGrader, the DBQs and the research paper go through Google Classroom or Canvas: 288 pieces of writing graded against an AP-style rubric from the library, with AI-writing and plagiarism checks on Pro. The 2,500-word papers fit Pro's 3,500-word limit. The unit tests are built and marked elsewhere, and their 576 short responses (96 students, two per test, three tests) are marked by hand or in another tool.

With IntelliAssess, the three unit tests are written from the teacher's slides, delivered online, and marked at hand-in, with the 576 short responses scored against a rubric for the teacher to review, and proctoring for any test sat at home. The DBQs and research paper do not fit: they are written over days with sources, outside a test, and IntelliAssess cannot grade them there.

With both, EssayGrader takes the long writing and IntelliAssess the tests. Billed yearly, that is about $14.99 a month for EssayGrader Pro and $39 a month for IntelliAssess Starter, with both sending grades to Google Classroom.

A closer look at EssayGrader's accuracy figure

EssayGrader says it tested its grading on 22,000 essays from The Learning Agency's dataset, and that its scores "matched or landed within 1 point of teacher scores 94% of the time". It is a large sample and a clearly stated measure. It is also EssayGrader's own study, on a research dataset of school essays; your prompts and rubric may behave differently, and "within one point" is looser than exact agreement. EssayGrader's ability to learn from your own graded essays is designed to close that gap for your marking. IntelliAssess has not published an accuracy study; it shows a reason for every criterion score so you can check the ones you doubt.

How far to trust the AI score

EssayGrader's 94% comes from its own study on a large, standardised essay set. A synthesis of 65 studies found AI-human agreement "highly context-dependent", and a 2025 university study found it "consistently low". Treat any AI score as a first pass and check it; both tools leave the final grade to you.

What the evidence says about AI essay scoring: CoGrader reports 98.3 percent within one point on 1,764 STAAR responses and EssayGrader 94 percent within one point on 22,000 essays, both vendor studies; a synthesis of 65 studies finds agreement highly context-dependent; a 2025 university study found agreement consistently low
Vendor studies against independent research.

Pricing

EssayGrader's Basic plan is free for up to 100 essays a month of up to 1,000 words. Pro is $14.99 a month for 350 essays of up to 3,500 words with AI-writing and plagiarism detection; Premium is $34.99 a month for 800 essays of up to 8,000 words. On 16 November 2026 those were the yearly-billing prices, with $19.99 and $49.99 for monthly billing. District and higher-education plans are quoted.

IntelliAssess's plans are sized by students, from Free for 25 to Intensive at $249 a month for 2,000, with AI grading and proctoring from Starter at $39. For essays alone, EssayGrader costs less.

AI-written work: checking the text or watching the writing

Take-home essays are where AI-written work worries teachers most, and the two tools respond differently. EssayGrader checks the submitted text on Pro and Premium, for plagiarism against existing sources and for signs of AI writing. A plagiarism match can point to a source; an AI-writing result is an estimate, because there is no original to point to, so treat it as a reason to talk with the student rather than as proof.

IntelliAssess does not check text. It moves the writing into a test and, if you turn proctoring on, shares the whole screen and checks the browser, so an AI tool open in another window appears in the report alongside webcam evidence. That only works for writing done inside the test, so it does not help with a research paper written over two weeks. Many teachers combine the two ideas: a take-home paper checked by EssayGrader, followed by a short supervised written response in class or online on the same topic, which shows whether the student can explain the argument in their own words.

When a test can do part of an essay's job

Not every piece of writing needs to be a full essay. A short constructed response in a timed test can check whether a student understands a cause, can use evidence, or can explain a concept, in a few minutes of writing and a few seconds of AI scoring per answer. That is where IntelliAssess fits: two or three written questions, each with a four-level rubric, inside a unit test with choice questions. It leaves the longer, researched writing, where students develop an argument over days, to the essay graders. Splitting the work this way can reduce how many full essays you mark each term without reducing how often students write.

Two kinds of trust

Ask two questions of any AI grader: is the score right, and is the work the student's own? EssayGrader answers the first with its 94% study and by learning from your graded essays, and the second with text checks. IntelliAssess answers the first by showing a reason for every criterion score, and the second by supervising the test. Neither answer is complete, so check a sample of scores against your own marking in the first weeks with either tool.

Word limits and volumes in practice

EssayGrader's plans limit both the number of essays a month and the length of each. Basic covers 100 essays a month of up to 1,000 words, which suits a teacher with two or three classes setting short essays. A teacher with 96 students setting one 1,500-word essay a month needs Pro, for the word limit as much as the count. A teacher marking 8,000-word extended essays needs Premium. IntelliAssess counts neither essays nor words: Starter covers up to 200 students, however many tests they sit, but its written answers are typed into a test, so long, researched writing is not what it is for.

Getting consistent AI scores in IntelliAssess

IntelliAssess does not learn from your past marking, so the rubric does that work. Write one idea per criterion, describe each level in terms you could point to in an answer, and keep the number of levels small. A written question with no rubric is left "not evaluated" rather than scored zero, and ungraded answers stay out of class averages until they are marked. Before using a new rubric on a full class, run five answers you have already marked through it and adjust any criterion where the AI disagrees with you.

Student data

Both tools process student writing, and IntelliAssess's proctoring also collects identity photos. IntelliAssess stores identity and evidence photos encrypted, opens them only through short-lived links, and records location only if you turn that check on. Our pages do not list certifications or data location, so ask us if your district needs them. We did not compare EssayGrader's privacy terms here; ask it whether student work, including the graded essays it learns from, is used to train models beyond your account, how long it is kept, and whether it has a data-privacy agreement with your district.

What students see

With EssayGrader, students see the scores and feedback their teacher has reviewed, synced back to Google Classroom, Canvas or Schoology, and EssayGrader supports revision cycles where they improve a draft and resubmit. With IntelliAssess, students see their marks and a comment per rubric criterion when results are released, a progress page with their scores over time, and a PDF of their own results. On Learning-purpose quizzes, on Pro and up, they can also get a short study plan built from their marks.

Monthly or yearly billing

EssayGrader's Pro and Premium prices of $14.99 and $34.99 a month were the yearly-billing prices when we read them on 16 November 2026; billed monthly they were $19.99 and $49.99. Over a school year of ten months, monthly billing for Pro comes to about $200, against about $180 for twelve months billed yearly. IntelliAssess's yearly billing works the same way in reverse: you pay for ten months, so Starter is $390 a year against $468 for twelve monthly payments.

Questions to ask before choosing

  1. Is my marking load mostly essays and papers written over days, or written answers inside tests?
  2. How long is the writing? Over 3,500 words needs EssayGrader Premium.
  3. Do I want a standards-aligned rubric ready, or do I mark against my own?
  4. Do I have graded essays I could upload so the tool learns my marking?
  5. Is AI-written work a concern for take-home writing, or for tests sat at home?
  6. Do I also need tests written and proctored?

Choose EssayGrader if

  • You grade many essays and long papers, including handwritten ones.
  • You want standards-aligned rubrics ready to use.
  • AI-writing and plagiarism checks matter for your assignments.
  • You want it to learn your grading from essays you have already marked.

Choose IntelliAssess if

  • Your tests combine choice questions and written answers.
  • You want the test written and proctored, not only graded.
  • Students sit exams at home and need identity checks.
  • You teach in Arabic.

Comparing more tools? See CoGrader and EssayGrader alternatives, CoGrader vs IntelliAssess, or every comparison.

Frequently asked questions

Is IntelliAssess an alternative to EssayGrader?

For tests, yes. For essays and papers written outside a test, EssayGrader is the specialist. IntelliAssess writes, proctors and grades whole tests, including written answers against your rubric.

How much does EssayGrader cost?

Free for 100 essays a month; Pro $14.99 a month for 350; Premium $34.99 for 800; districts quoted. Read on 17 November 2026.

Does EssayGrader detect AI-written essays?

Yes, on Pro and Premium, along with plagiarism checks. IntelliAssess does not check text for AI writing; its proctoring watches the screen for AI tools during a test.

Can EssayGrader grade handwriting?

Yes. Scan the class into one PDF and it separates and grades each essay. IntelliAssess grades only answers typed into its own tests.

How accurate is EssayGrader?

Its own study on 22,000 essays reports scores within one point of teacher scores 94% of the time. Independent research finds AI-human agreement varies widely, so review each score.

Can I use EssayGrader and IntelliAssess together?

Yes. Use EssayGrader for essays, DBQs and papers written outside a test, and IntelliAssess for tests that mix choice questions and written answers. Both send grades to Google Classroom.

Does IntelliAssess grade DBQs or research papers?

Not when they are written outside its tests. IntelliAssess grades written answers typed into its own tests. For DBQs and research papers, EssayGrader or CoGrader fit better.

Does EssayGrader learn how I grade?

Yes. It says it learns from essays you upload with your grades, so its drafts move closer to your marking. IntelliAssess's pages do not describe that; you change any criterion score yourself.

Which is cheaper for a teacher?

For essays alone, EssayGrader: free for 100 a month, or Pro at $14.99 a month billed yearly for 350. IntelliAssess Starter is $39 a month, or $390 a year, and also covers writing, delivering and proctoring tests for up to 200 students.

Can EssayGrader grade essays in Canvas?

Yes. EssayGrader syncs grades and feedback with Google Classroom, Canvas and Schoology. IntelliAssess works with Google Classroom only.

Does EssayGrader read handwritten essays?

Yes. Its Paper Grader takes a whole class scanned into one PDF, separates each student's pages and reads cursive and print. IntelliAssess grades only answers typed into its own tests, so handwritten work stays with EssayGrader or CoGrader.

What happens if the AI score is wrong?

In both tools you change it before students see it. EssayGrader drafts scores and comments for you to review, adjust and share. IntelliAssess shows a score and reason for each rubric criterion, and you can change any of them before releasing results. If the same criterion keeps going wrong, reword it in the rubric and test it again on a few answers.

Was this helpful?

About the author

Motasem Aldiab

Technology Consultant and Trainer - Cloud, DevOps, Java, Data Science

Dr. Motasem Abdelghani Aldiab is an academic and technology expert with a PhD in Computer Engineering from Queen’s University Belfast, UK, specializing in IP packet classification and next-generation networks. He holds an MSc in Telecommunications with Distinction and a BSc in Electrical Engineering. With experience in academia, software development, and IT consulting, his expertise spans cloud computing, Java technologies, web and mobile application development, and service-oriented architecture (SOA). He is also a Certified Cloud Architect and a certified trainer in cloud computing and SOA.

All articles
Limited time offer

10 lucky teachers get Pro free for 1 month

Collect 100 points with a few simple tasks. The first 10 teachers get the code.

10 of 10 spots left

Start collecting points

New here? Create a free teacher account